Showing posts with label #employee engagement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #employee engagement. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 June 2013

CEO's still not seeing (or believing) the link between employee engagement and the bottom line?

According to research published this week by Ashridge Business School some CEO’s are still struggling to “engage with engagement”.
This despite the fact that the UK clearly has an employee engagement problem.  Survey after survey in recent years shows that only about a third of UK workers consider themselves engaged – a figure which leaves the UK ranked ninth for engagement levels amongst the world’s twelve largest economies as ranked by GDP (Kenexa 2009).
In November last year Dr Bruce Rayton, from the School of Management at the University of Bath, co-author of another report entitled ‘The Evidence’ – concurred with this figure and suggested this effectively means that two thirds of UK workers (20 million people!), feel they have “more to offer” at work, that they’re not performing to their full capability and potential.
Incidentally, I still hear discussions about whether the business case for employee engagement is proven!  Well if it’s not common sense that workers not performing to their capability isn’t good for any organisation, ‘The Evidence’ report also concluded that the total cost to the UK economy of poor levels of engagement is £26 billion.   And Dr Rayton said: “Engagement predicts future performance better than performance predicts future engagement. In particular, engagement predicts performance several years into the future.
“Engagement occupies a central role in “service profit chains”, with employee engagement leading to improved customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and customer advocacy which in turn drives future sales, operating profits and other financial outcomes”, he added.
And just in case there’s still any doubt, according to Hay “94% of the world’s most admired companies believe that their efforts to engage their employees have created a competitive advantage”.
Back to the latest Ashridge research, entitled ‘Engagement through CEO eyes’.  The research explored the topic of engagement during a year long study with 16 UK CEO’s.  It sought to find out how leaders define engagement, what stops them from leading in an engaging way and why engagement is not happening more in the UK.
It indicated that CEOs define engagement as an “organisational climate in which people choose to give the very best of themselves at work”.  No surprise there.  The CEO’s concluded that “being an engaging leader is hard and requires special skills and attributes” and that there is no single ‘right way’ to lead to achieve engagement, although a ‘command and control’ leadership style has declining relevance in a leaders job.  The report suggested that some leaders feel the difficult economic conditions of recent times is being used as an excuse for poor leadership behaviours.
One CEO said that “It is very easy when companies or countries are in crisis to have command and control and a belief that it needs a hero leader who is telling people what to do to actually get the thing moving forward”.  And several indicated that the challenges of the economy make it easier to ignore engagement, suggesting that it’s tempting to ‘;do what you’ve always done and wait for things to get better rather than do something different, and perhaps uncomfortable.
In terms of the things that stop leaders from leading engagement, the culture and system of UK business was seen as one of the main challenges.  CEO’s believed that organisational hierarchy and a focus on short-term* results are diametrically opposed to creating engagement.  Some leaders clearly still don’t see (or perhaps believe) the connection between engagement and the bottom line.
Other barriers identified in the report were shortcomings in leadership capability, for example poor self-awareness and having limited “emotional connections”, such as being open to feedback and sharing power.  Also traits like ‘leader pride’ may lead to behaviours inconsistent with creating engagement.  One CEO said: “There’s a whole set of worries that goes on with people, most of us like to be popular and actually you can’t.”
However, the good news is that some of the CEO’s talked about how the future of leadership needs to have engagement at its core, particularly given the differing expectations of a multi-generational workforce.  One said: “I think big corporations have got a massive challenge if they think they’re going to retain talented people through command and control and not including them into decision-making and creative processes early on.”
The report concludes that engagement is the better way to release the full capabilities and potential of people at work and in so doing to enable organisational growth and ultimately economic growth for the UK.

I agree - but more CEO's need to 'get it' first.
www.inaccord.co.uk
LinkedIn: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @Inaccord_UK
Telephone: +44 (0) 7906 650019
My main blog now appears at www.inaccord.co.uk - please follow future blogs at that url.
*I wrote about the problems of short termism almost 18 months ago.  First here: http://www.inaccord.co.uk/a-customer-engagement-manifesto-for-2012/

These issues are still current, and still a big problem!

Monday, 18 February 2013

How employees hang themselves on the coat-stand by the door?

Whilst chatting to a friend over a beer yesterday I was reminded about a story I heard several years ago, told by the poet, author and speaker David Whyte.

My friend started a new job last spring and, having not seen him since the summer, I was asking him how it was going.  He explained it was "OK", in my experience usually an indication of something less than perfect!  There was undoubtedly a tinge of disappointment in his voice as he said it, which surprised me given how excited he'd been back then.  As we continued to talk he told me that he felt the reason he'd got the job in the first place was because of the skills he had, and that they'd explicitly said that those skills could benefit them.

Less than a year later though he said that the opportunities to use those skills had been limited.  They'd told him that they'd try some of his ideas in the future "when the time was right".  He said that he'd tried to show initiative and progress some new ideas anyway but was asked by not to do so unless he first had explicit approval.  So he lowered his sights a little and worked on incremental improvements to processes which, when it came to the attention of senior management, again met with a negative response.  The outcome is that he's become noticeably less enthusiastic and even a little weary of it all.  I talked to him about possible responses and how best to remain positive and add value such that he got more independence and he said that "for the time being I'm going to keep my head down and hopefully some opportunities might arise in the future".

David Whyte's story came to mind afterwards when I was driving home.  He explained how many new starters go into their role with excitement and expectation about the positive contribution they are going to make.  They enthusiastically throw themselves into the role each day, seeking ways to be as effective as they can and make the most effective contribution.  They do what they are good at and intuitively use their skills.  But then they meet barriers, they hear people talking about "the way things are done around here", and are told "if you want to get on you have to .....".  And so they start to subjugate themselves and who they really are to fit in - metaphorically speaking they take who they really are off at the door and hang themselves on the coat-stand.  At first they pick themselves up again every night before hanging themselves us again the next morning.  But as the expectation of who they should be at work in order to fit in grows, and they become more and more familiar with the person they believe they should be, sooner or later they just pick themselves up at weekends.  And sometimes, if they stay long enough, the real 'them' eventually stays on the coat-stand permanently.  They become the person they think they should be to fit in with the culture at work, losing who they really are altogether.



Sometimes I talk to people who have been in the same organisation for many years and they talk wistfully about who they used to be and what they once wanted to do, and achieve.  These are sure signs of people who have left part of themselves on the coat-stand.

An organisational culture that results in people bringing only part of themselves to their role can't be a good thing for an organisation that wants to succeed can it?  What's best, a culture in which people comply or one in which people authentically use all of their skills, their attributes and their qualities for the benefit of the organisation?

How many of your people hang themselves on the coat-stand by the door?

LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: (0044) 07906650019

Monday, 7 January 2013

Same old same old - back on the chain gang

Isn't it strange how sometimes days seem to have a theme?  I had one of those days today - the theme: back to work (or school) after the holidays.

It started first thing this morning with my 10 year old daughter telling me how excited she was about going back to school.  Somewhat surprised, I asked her why and she explained that "I'm getting a bit bored at home all the time and it'll be good to see my teacher and friends again."  Reassuring affirmation of the quality of the school she attends.

A little later, as I was getting into my car, I got into a conversation with my next door neighbour.  When I asked him if he was back to work today he sighed and said something like: "Unfortunately yes, back on the chain gang.....".

Subsequently I rang a client and after exchanging the obligatory happy New Year sentiments I asked if today was her first day back in the office.  Her response: "Yes, new year but same old challenges!"  Later this afternoon, a similar exchange with another client who used very similar words "Same old problems though, nothing bloody changes!"

And then, whilst driving home, the DJ on the Drivetime programme on Radio 2 said he was playing 'Same old, same old' themed songs to reflect the numbers of people back to work / school today.

What struck me most about all this was that most people (my daughter excluded!) seemed genuinely fed-up about going back, their words summarising how they felt and the underlying meaning of the key phrases perhaps being particularly telling:

'Same old same old': an idiom for when a situation remains the same, especially when it is boring or annoying;

'Chain gang': phrase describing when convicts were chained together for outdoor labour.

It's a sad state of affairs if that's really how people feel about returning to work.  And the evidence suggests it is.  Depending on which statistics you trust, levels of engagement have been at best stagnant over the last three or four years and less than one in three employees is truly engaged with their employer.  The approach most companies are following clearly isn't consistently producing the results they want.  So what's the problem and what do practitioners need to do about it?

I'll cover this in my blog this Friday (January 11th)......

By the way, I know this is going off at a bit of a tangent but I've had two songs in my head all evening, both fitting the theme.  They're here:
 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RmZdvVnMXCc
and
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CK3uf5V0pDA

Two great songs from different decades, at least in my opinion.  Enjoy!

LinkedIn: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: 0044 07906650019

Wednesday, 2 January 2013

The value of good deeds in a naughty world

I did a lot of reading during the Christmas and New Year break and some of the stuff I read really stimulated my thinking.  One article particularly resonated with me - and I wanted to share it with you in my first post of 2013. 

It was entitled 'Why kindness can help businesses grow' and was essentially about Henrietta Lovell, a UK based entrepreneur who is gaining quite a reputation as she grows her business: the Rare Tea Company.  It tells the story of how, after an experience of drinking a wonderful tea in Hong Kong, she began to question the quality of the big brand teas available in UK supermarkets and realised that the tea she had fallen for in Hong Kong was simply not available in the UK.

She travelled to tea-growing places in China and Africa, and "fell in love with tea and the people who grew it."  And as a result she started her Rare Tea Company to sell some of the enticing teas she bought straight from the growers in exotic places.

Much of the rest of the article details how, as a result of extraordinary acts of kindness, she has been able to rapidly grow the Rare Tea Company brand and her own reputation.

The author of the article, Peter Day, then goes on to comment on the "business of kindness", as he calls it.  He writes:
"Why shouldn't this be another way of doing business, far removed from the brash competitiveness that businesses think they are all about? There is, surely, far more to running a company than the preposterous cut-throat competition of the TV challenge show, The Apprentice.

Why can't businesses be run with a generosity of spirit and a lot of goodwill? Henrietta Lovell says it can be done, but hers may be just a good deed in a naughty world.
I would like to think not. It may be the start of a trend. Companies have got away with nominal good behaviour for years. They do what their lawyers and their marketing people tell them they are obligated to do, and nothing much more.

As the banking crisis demonstrated, they did what they could get away with, driven by what they maintained was the interests of their shareholders, and the bosses revelling in the status symbol of their bonuses.

Now blinking in the glare of publicity - businesses may be waking up to other, more deep-seated, obligations. Good people may in the end decide they do not want to work for inhuman or merely operationally effective companies. They will want more from work than pay and promotion. They will want to be nice. They will want the organisations they work for to be kind.

That is what customers are discovering they want, too. They want to deal with businesses that work in decent ways, that reflect their own feelings about the world."

There's no doubt in my mind that he's right.  This trend has been underway for some time already, and I'm convinced it's going to accelerate in the coming years.  It's the big opportunity for businesses that respond to it, and a huge risk for those that don't.

Peter Day goes on to write: "It would be nice to think that the business of kindness will not be captured by professional marketeers and become just another device for paying lip service to how people think business ought to behave.

It would be nice to be un-cynical about it. It would be nice to think that kindness is a way of doing business that might infect lots of big business rather than just a few pioneers."

I guess we'll see.....

The full article can be found here: Why kindness can help businesses grow

Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: 0044 07906650019