Showing posts with label Culture Change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Culture Change. Show all posts

Monday, 26 March 2012

The Problem with Change

In a world in which the pace of change is ever greater, and in an economy in which an inability to change can literally mean business failure, it's critical for businesses to be able to introduce and embed change rapidly and effectively. And yet, research has proven that most change activity fails to deliver the desired benefits. It doesn't seem to matter what the exact nature of the change is, change consistently fails:

• As many as 70% of mergers fail to deliver their intended benefits (CIPD, 2003)
• Re-engineering costs too much and takes too long and expected synergies aren’t achieved (Kotter, 1996)
• When poor integration occurs, leadership attrition soars by 47% within 3 years, productivity drops by 50% and employee satisfaction drops by 14% (Shuler and Jackson, 2001)
• The most common challenges cited are ‘soft’ issues; in particular ‘changing mindsets and the
existing corporate culture’ (IBM, 2008)

Considerable time and money has been spent trying to understand why, so that the process of change can be made more effective. But here's my view of the most important reason: when change is planned, the people elements are usually the last to be considered and have the least robust plans. Organisations rigorously plan plan the financials, the process, the operations etc. but few plan the people experience. Or at least few plan the people experience effectively.

And unsurprisingly this causes issues during implementation, which impact the effectiveness of the change:
  • The process of delivering the change often disengages people emotionally, meaning they don’t support it
  • The role managers play in the transformation is often disregarded , and they are critical in engaging people rationally and emotionally (both elements are critical for sustainable change)
  • Communications are too mechanical and logical and fail to engage people emotionally
  • Individuals' agendas are disregarded , and people are left unclear about “what this means for me”
  • There is no method for gathering feedback from people throughout the change process, so it’s unclear whether people are ‘on-board’ until it’s too late

Don't put the people elements last. Put them right at the top of the agenda, prioritise the people experience through change, and the desired benefits will be realised and sustained more effectively.

LinkedIn: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: 0044 07906650019

Monday, 30 January 2012

The Spiral of Culture Change

My last two blogs have been about culture change. And I’m continuing the theme today....
I believe there are a number of common stages any organisation must go through in order to change culture, at least if the change is going to be sustained. Here’s my view on the spiral, the process to follow to dramatically increase the probability of successful, lasting change,
and a brief explanation of each stage?
Stage 1 - Create a compelling purpose
People who are going to be subject to any change need to understand what the changes will be and why they are necessary. And they need to feel that the reasons for change are valid, that they’re important and that after the change has occurred the outcome will be positive. So it’s critical to spend time at the outset establishing why the change is required and how to communicate it in a compelling way, so that it’s seen as important. It’s easier sometimes than others.
I once worked for an organisation who explained the need for a change programme by clarifying that the business was at risk and that unless change occurred quickly everyone’s jobs were also at risk. Hearing a message like that tends to focus the mind! On the other hand, the business may not be at risk, if might be performing reasonably well, and culture change is more about improvement and becoming even better. The compelling purpose then is probably more about painting a vision of just how bright the future could be. Some people are drawn towards change
whilst others move away from the present – if the risks of staying put are strong enough. Cater for both scenarios are provide a message that people can hear, irrespective of what motivates them to change.
Stage 2 - Catalyse leadership
Leaders in any organisation play a key role in causing, supporting and accelerating change – or not. If they aren’t supportive of the proposed change the likelihood of it succeeding reduces considerably. It’s therefore very important to ensure that people in positions of power and influence in the organisation are on-board and support the change. You will want their support not just in terms of the words they use but also in their actions and behaviour. It’s worth taking a little longer at the outset to ensure their support.

Stage 3 - Understand personal impacts
It’s all very well asking leaders to support culture change, but how can they really do that if they don’t understand what the likely impacts are for them personally. The human brain is
genetically programmed to seek clarity and certainty about the future. The likelihood of any individual supporting change tends to be in direct contrast to the degree of clarity they have about what the change will mean for them. If the change is likely to be positive then naturally, people will be more enthusiastic than if it is likely to be negative but it’s still better, always,
to provide clarity on what’s known – even if the impact is likely to be negative. Usually, even negative changes can be reframed to find some positives.
This of course holds true for everyone in the organisation and not just leaders. The fuller the
explanation of the proposed changes the greater the success of the change over the long term.

Stage 4 - Understand organisational constraints and enablers
In his excellent book ‘The Unwritten Rules of the Game’, Dr. Peter Scott-Morgan explained how the unwritten rules impact the success or failure of any and all organisational change. He stressed that no matter how clear and detailed the policies and procedures of an organisation, the key conditions impacting it are the things that aren’t written down anywhere but nevertheless influence how people behave every day.
Consider your organisation. What is the honest advice you’d give a friend about how to get on in
it? How would they need to behave and why? What are the most important things to say (or not say)? What are the most important things to do (and not do)? Who should they seek to get on well with and who should they avoid? Given all that, how should they be when they’re at work and overall, what should they do? The answers to these questions are likely to be the unwritten rules of your organisation, or at least of your department in the organisation. If you were to ask enough people to answer questions like these, you’d start to build a picture of the unwritten rules at play, and how they affect how it operates.
And the key thing to remember is that they interfere with any organisational initiative that seeks to change the way people behave. It’s possible that they will support the desired culture change but if they don’t, left unchanged they will dramatically increase the likelihood of it failing. That’s
why it doesn’t make much sense to seek to change culture without first having an understanding of the current culture, and why it’s how it is.
Stage 5 - Design the plan
So you understand what the desired change is, you understand how it’s going to impact people and the unwritten rules in the organisation that might enable or constrain it. The next stage
is to decide what actions are needed to cause the change to actually happen, how best to sequence them, how they will fit with other things happening in the organisation, who will be responsible for implementing them – and so on. Actions properly planned and delivered are
always more likely to succeed than those that aren’t.
Stage 6 - Take action
Once the groundwork has been done, it’s time to take action and implement the plan.
Stage 7 - Monitor and measure progress
As the plan is being implemented and actions taken, it’s makes sense to monitor the results and measure progress towards the desired change. However, be conscious that it might take a
little time to see changes, so don’t change course too soon. If the previous stages have been undertaken well, the change will happen in time.
Culture is difficult to change and it’s wise therefore to position any culture change activity as ongoing and not a short term programme. Those organisations who approach changing culture as a project which once down can be shut down and focus switched to something else don’t really understand the nature of cultivating something long term and are more than likely to fail....
For more information or help with the stages:
LinkedIn: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: (0044) 07906650019

Tuesday, 24 January 2012

Why Organisations Don’t Try to Cultivate Culture #Culturechange

I haven’t come across an executive who is unaware that there is a culture at work within his or her organisation. I’ve met a few who haven’t made the link between culture and the performance of their business but the majority seem to understand that the two things are inextricably linked. I’m therefore surprised how often there’s no conscious, planned activity underway to shape their culture or continuing the theme from yesterday, to cultivate it.

Either consciously or unconsciously, every organisation is shaping their culture. The way in which it responds to internal and external influences, the manner in which decisions are taken and the impact of those decisions, the tone of communications, the behaviours of managers and leaders, the things they recognise and reward, the behaviours they encourage, things they give attention to and talk about (or not), things they tolerate or turn a blind eye to.....are all examples of ways that they cultivate their culture, irrespective of whether they are aware of it or not.

Ignorance of the link between culture and performance is may be an excuse for them,
albeit a poor one! So what's the excuse in organisations where executives do understand the link but still don’t consciously and deliberately cultivate it?

In my experience there are four key reasons:

  1. Fear
    This is a reflection of the human fear of change. We might not like our current circumstances but stay where we are because if we change it might be even worse. “Better the devil you know” and all that. It’s fear of losing control, of making things worse, fear of trying to change and failing, fear of succeeding and having a new set of problems, fear of the unknown. When fear is the dominant driver in the business it will be slow to change, slow to react to changes in the market – and at risk.
  2. Complacency
    Organisations that have no burning platform for change are often complacent. Results will typically be ok, not great but also not poor enough to make change unavoidable. So the “we’ve always done it that way” and “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” mentality prevails. These organisations will be ‘comfortable’ places to work, but not great places that encourage and stimulate people to achieve more. These organisations are insular and not particularly concerned about what competitors are doing – and consequently are at risk. See Kodak for an example.
  3. Habit
    When the senior team in an organisation gets too comfortable and habitual ways of managing become embedded, it becomes difficult for leaders to step outside their comfort zone and drive change. It becomes in their best interests to safeguard the status quo – because the alternative would mean them changing. Decisions are communicated and if challenged, explained by suffixing “because the Chairman / CEO says so”. Leaders in these organisations might be perceived as arrogant and disinterested in change and these behaviours put the organisation at risk.
  4. Degree of difficulty
    Some organisations know they should change their culture, thet want to but just don't know how to do it. They perhaps can’t put their finger on what’s wrong currently, and consequently they don’t know exactly what needs to change, and even if they do they don’t know what actions to take to do it or how long it will take, how employees will react, or who
    needs to do what. These organisations are ambitious for change but don’t know where to start and so stress is part and parcel of working there, because it’s hard work overcoming the difficulties inherent in the culture. They experience other organisations doing what they do ......but doing it better and this puts them at risk.

And then there are organisations who understand it and are consciously and deliberately shaping and cultivating their culture. It's a culture that is aligned with their vision, their strategy and their business objectives. They're the organisations you admire and respect AND are achieving extraordinary performance.

What group is your organisation in?

Get in touch, I'd like to help......


LinkedIn: http://uk.linkedin.com/in/timhadfield
Twitter: @accordengage
Telephone: 0044 7906 650019